Doubt by Yoshiki Tonogai

This is what I feel don’t fit together, it fells like Tonogai is forcing it too much.

Mitsuki and Yu had been friend since childhood, for people to have such friends I find it really weird if Yu didn’t know that Mitsuki’s father had passed away. I had a friend since highschool, we’ve been friend for more than15 years. During those years, I’ve known all her family member, I knew when something bad happens to her family and it is vice versa. So, HOW COME Yu who is always looking after Mitsuki didn’t know that his best friend’s father had passed away?

The other thing that makes it even weirder is about Rei, she was very famous for both her phenomenal in hypnosis and her scandal when people started calling her a liar. And the not long after that, her parents tried to do suicide by crashing their car into a cliff. Rei survived from the crash and started putting seed of hypnosis through television set. For someone that famous, wouldn’t her accident be a national news? Wouldn’t everyone know that she was still standing in her two feet even after the crash?

To make matter worst, Mitsuki and Yu liked to watch Rei’s show when they were little. Both Mitsuki and Yu should have known that Rei is a normal girl.

Last, Hajime said that he makes Haruka’s body looks like Mitsuki’s body to make the real wolf comes out….How could he do such a thing? Haruka and Mitsuki’s clothes are different. If by chance Hajime found Mitsuki’s cloth lying around on the floor, wouldn’t he suspect her already without jumping onto Yu?

These three facts make my rating on the manga lesser than what I actually planned for it. Without those two weird connections, I would have given it 5 stars but I ended up giving it 3 stars.

19 Comments

  1. Huahahaha, gila ini manga lumayan keren, ending-nya gak terduga. 😀
    Saya ama adik saya sepakat ini anime mirip kayak “SAW”, tapi dengan ending yang bener2 mengejutkan. Sangat mengejutkan. 🙂

    1. Yup…manga yg keren, akan jauh lebih bagus jika tanpa kekurangan2 yg sy tulis di halaman 2. Bagian2 tersebut terkesan maksa bgt. Tp overall baguslah.

  2. I think next year I’m going to try some manga since you are such a big reader for it. I will keep these in mind. They sound pretty good. I have Cowboy Bebop and also Akira and Ghost in the Shell so I’ll read those first, but after that I’ll raid your blog for suggestions!

    1. Unfortunately, I don’t read manga as much as I used to. Nowadays mangas are so childish. But I always keep my eyes open for more complicated manga.
      I’m now trying to re-read old manga that I have read before I made my blog so that I can review them better. The old mangas are better than nowadays mangas, in my opinion.

      I have watched anime of Akira and Ghost In the Shell years ago, but I haven’t read the manga yet.

  3. This sounds good as well but as I wrote before I never read a Manga and still think I will try One Piece first. I can get it easily here so that’s good too.

    1. I should warn you that One Piece is VERY long!!! For me, it is the best Manga ever written so I don’t mind if it Reached 100 volumes. For a new Manga reader, you should try shorter ones like this, it only consists of 4 volumes

    1. I can understand, it is a bit difficult to start something new, I have been reading manga since I was still in junior high.

      Hahaha don’t worry…sometimes there was only me for a couple of week. Most of the participants will show up at the last days

  4. waaaaaa ini bagus ya miss? udah lama tertarik pengen beli tiap ke toko buku tapi ga jadi mulu.. kalo emang bagus jadi beli deh ntar klo ke toko buku lagi, moga2 masih ada >_<

    1. Kemungkinan besar UDAH GA ADA, hehe sy nyari yg ketiga aja smp keliling kesana kemari. Yg kesatu harus DL.

      Level comic terbatas bgt sih kalo nyetak komiknya.

  5. This does sound like an interesting short manga series, even with the plot holes you mentioned. One of the main reasons I haven’t read more manga (other than never having enough time to do everything I want to) is because it’s hard to know which ones have complicated, interesting stories for adults. Like you said, there are so many childish ones. Thanks as always for joining in Hello Japan! and for your enthusiasm! 🙂

    1. You can do the same thing as I always do…go with your hunch 😉 There are a lot of great manga out there.

      No thanks needed 🙂 I enjoy your challenge and one of my favorite challenges. It has turned into a monthly post for me.

  6. nie mangaaaaaaaaa is the beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeest@!!!!!!!!!!! aku dah baca all of them dan sempat keliru nebak pelakunyaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa, aku gak nyangka *** pelaku nyaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa……….. tapi ni manga patut dibaca

    1. Hi Redian
      Wah senangnya ada juga yang suka sama manga ini. Sayangnya manga ini susah bgt dicarinya. Gw dah dapat semua volumenya, yang pertama gw dapat di toko buku bekas.

      Maaf ya, komennya sy edit karena aga spoiler ntar jadi ngebocorin cerita 😉

  7. In fact, there are many flaws on this manga, aside from that you’ve been mentioned. Some things just doesn’t follow the logic. The artwork is what keep me entertaining though. Judge, as a sequel to Doubt, has a similar premise. Let’s see what will happen next…

    1. I agree…but the one I mentioned is the one that annoyed me the most…it’s like a fatal mistake.

      I have judge but not complete…so I haven’t read it yet.

Say something so I know you have read my post, THANK YOU for reading :)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s